The best tomato soup you’ll ever make

Miss Thrifty6 May 23, 2014

tomato soup recipe

Look, I don’t even like tomato soup! Especially not the claggy version that comes in tins. This homemade version, however, is the cat’s miaow: it is fresh and full of flavour, and I’d happily slurp it by the bucket-load. This is a recipe from my talented Frugal Grandma so, as you would expect, it is as delightfully inexpensive and simple as it is delicious.

Actually, I had a tough time wheedling this one out of Frugal Grandma. She says that she has made tomato soup like this for the past 60 years, but has never made it exactly the same way twice. We got there in the end.

When I say it is inexpensive, there is a caveat: this recipe depends upon you having a lot of tomatoes to hand. Frugal Grandma grows tomatoes by the glut, as do I. (Incidentally, at the end of the growing season, I still draw upon these 1940s tips to avoid wasting unripened fruit.) Frugal Grandma, overrun by shiny homegrown tomatoes, avoids waste by making this soup in batch.

If you are thinking of growing tomatoes this year but haven’t yet walked the walk, it isn’t too late to do so: at this time of year, the young plants are bustin’ out of their little pots and a lot of the garden centres, shops and front-garden sellers are selling them for pennies.

The other reason why I like this tomato soup recipe is that it uses up what I think of as salad drawer scraps: the odds and ends left to wilt in the bottom of the fridge. This recipe is best made with ripe tomatoes, so if you have a carton of supermarket tomatoes going squishy in there, here’s another good way to use them up. Unless you have a lot of squishy tomatoes, however, you may wish to downsize the quantities below, which fill a large saucepan. (Here is my other favourite way to use up squishy tomatoes.)

Without further ado, here’s the recipe:

The Best Tomato Soup You’ll Ever Make


1 kg ripe tomatoes

1 large onion, chopped

1 carrot, finely grated

Any leftover celery, finely chopped

Chopped garlic cloves, to taste

1/4 tsp dried marjoram or oregano (better still, fresh marjoram/oregano if you have it)

500 ml water

1/2 a small carton of double cream

2 tbsp fresh basil, chopped (or 1 tsp dried basil)

Any left over pieces of pepper, finely chopped.



1. Chop tomatoes. Don’t bother skinning them: truly, life is too short.

2. Heat a little oil in a large pan, and cook the onion, carrot and celery over a low heat until the onions begin to turn translucent.

3. Add the tomatoes, garlic and marjoram.

4. Cook over a low heat until everything in the pan has softened.

5. Add water, cover and simmer for about 45 minutes.

6. Blend in batches. Return the soup to the saucepan with basil, salt and pepper and reheat.

7. Add the cream, but be careful not to boil it. Serve.


Frugal Grandma’s Notes:

* Adding the cream: I prefer to let the soup cool, then I add the cream and stir well before pouring the soup into cartons for the freezer.

* I always like to serve tomato soup with a swirl of cream for decoration.

* Very important: add anything you like to this soup. It all adds flavour!

  recipe for tomato soup

If you have the tomatoes already, the rest of the ingredients amount to less than £1. If you need to buy tomatoes, you can currently pick up 1 kg of cherry tomatoes from Morrisons for around £3. This tomato soup recipe makes enough to fill several bowls, so either way the cost per serving is low. I like to serve Frugal Grandma’s tomato soup with homemade bread: again, the cost is pennies.

Did you enjoy this post?

Free Daily Digest

6 Responses to “The best tomato soup you’ll ever make

judy says:

I’m going to make this–sounds won derful

May 23, 2014 at 4:22 pm

Lucy says:

My dad used to make wonderful tomato soup, always at christmas, he also used to grow many fruits and vegetable in the garden, the whole back garden was full to the brim with them. Sadly I can’t find out his recipe as he passed away 11 years ago but its a happy memory that I will always have, amongst many others.

May 24, 2014 at 8:54 am

We love tomato soup! We use a different recipe where we make it using four different kinds of tomato (fresh soft ones, cans, tomato paste and passata). Wonderful! Soups, I find are generally very healthy and inexpensive to eat (and very easy to cook).

May 25, 2014 at 4:49 pm

judy says:

homemade tomato soup is so worth the effort

May 25, 2014 at 5:09 pm

It sounds delicious! I’m look forward to giving it a try.

May 27, 2014 at 6:22 am

Jennelle says:

I made this recipe for a 1940’s party. The gals loved it! We are having another one, and they are just begging me to make some more. 😀 Thank you so much!

September 15, 2015 at 9:31 pm

Leave a reply

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *